Midnight Moves
Rye · Carpano Antica · Rainwater Madeira · Kirschwasser · Crème de Cacao
Recipe by Miles Macquarrie / @lois_must_die — Kimball House, Atlanta
Macquarrie described Midnight Moves as something he had wanted to make for years: a Black Forest gateau as a Manhattan. The ingredients read like a dessert menu — Kirschwasser, crème de cacao, cherry-heavy Carpano Antica — but the rye and Rainwater Madeira keep it from becoming one. This is a stirred, spirit-forward cocktail served up in a wide antique coupe. No garnish. The drink announces itself.
Freezer-Door Batch (1L)
Note on the bitters: add them per-glass at service, not to the batch. Mole bitters shift significantly over time in large-format batches and can overpower. The double dropper is generous — this drink wants the chocolate-chili note prominent.
Single Serve
Why This Drink Exists
The Black Forest gateau is a German confection built on three flavors: chocolate, cherry, and whipped cream. Midnight Moves translates two of the three into a Manhattan framework — Kirschwasser for the cherry spirit, crème de cacao for the chocolate — and uses Carpano Antica's natural vanilla and dark cherry character to do the work that cream would do in the pastry. The rye is the structure underneath, and the mole bitters connect chocolate to chili-spice in a way that pushes the drink away from dessert and into something darker.
The Rainwater Madeira is the move that makes it work. Rainwater is the lightest, most delicate style of Madeira — not the rich, heavy Malmsey or Bual, but something closer to a dry fortified wine with a nutty, slightly oxidative character. It keeps the drink from becoming too heavy while adding a layer of complexity that prevents it from being simply a flavored Manhattan.
Macquarrie had wanted to make this drink for years. That kind of patient intention shows in how precisely calibrated it is — nothing is accidental, nothing is extra. The wide coupe and the lack of garnish are the final editorial decisions: nothing to distract from what's in the glass.
The Flavor Arc
What Each Ingredient Brings
Rye Whiskey
High-rye mashbill (51%+ rye grain) produces a drier, spicier whiskey than bourbon. Rittenhouse 100 proof or Pikesville Straight Rye both work well here — the proof helps the spirit hold its own against the vermouth and liqueurs.
The chassis. Without rye's assertiveness, Carpano's richness and the sweet liqueurs would tip the balance into dessert territory. The spice is structural.
Carpano Antica Formula
A premium Italian sweet vermouth with an unusually rich, vanilla-heavy flavor profile. Made from a 19th-century recipe that includes vanilla, cocoa, and bitter herbs. Markedly different from French-style sweet vermouth.
The closest thing to cream in this Black Forest translation. Carpano's vanilla and dark cherry notes are what make the gateau reference legible. A drier vermouth would lose the connection.
Rainwater Madeira
The lightest, most delicate style of Madeira — historically associated with American colonial trade. Slightly sweet, nutty, with a gentle oxidative character. Much lighter than Malmsey or Bual.
The complexity bridge. It sits between the rye's grain notes and the vermouth's richness without taking over. Remove it and the drink becomes a very good but less interesting flavored Manhattan.
Kirschwasser
Dry cherry eau de vie distilled from fermented Morello cherries, originating in the Black Forest region of Germany. No added sugar. Clear, sharp, intensely cherry-aromatic without any of the sweetness of maraschino or cherry liqueur.
The most essential ingredient for the Black Forest reference. This is the cherry in the gateau — dry, not sweet, with real fruit character. Substituting maraschino would sweeten the drink significantly and lose the connection to the original concept.
Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters
A cocktail bitters built around cacao nib and cinnamon, with additional chili heat. Named for mole — the Mexican sauce that brings chocolate, chili, and dried fruit together.
The connective tissue. The mole bitters tie the crème de cacao's chocolate to the Kirschwasser's cherry and the Carpano's spice in a way that suggests the gateau without being literal. The chili heat is what keeps the drink savory.
Variations to Explore
Bourbon Build
Replace rye with a wheated bourbon — Maker's Mark or W.L. Weller. Softer, sweeter entry. The Black Forest reference gets more explicit.
More dessert-forward. Better for guests who find rye too dry.
Amaro Swap
Replace the Rainwater Madeira with Averna or Montenegro amaro. The herbal bitterness and caramel notes add a different kind of complexity.
Darker and more bitter. Loses the oxidative delicacy but gains amaro's bitter-sweet richness.
Mezcal Riff
Replace 0.5 oz of rye with reposado mezcal. The smoke plays surprisingly well against the mole bitters.
An unexpected direction — chocolate and smoke together are coherent. Worth trying if you have mezcal on hand.
Midnight Moves is a drink built from years of patience. You can taste the precision. Order it in Atlanta. Make it at home. No garnish.
← Back to Cocktails